MAKE OPINIONS VISIBLE.
English

Confidence voting: what a result actually tells you

A confidence vote asks about confidence in a shared undertaking. It reveals assessments that can disappear in an open discussion. Its value lies in the conversation that follows, not in achieving the highest possible number.

Sign in with your facil4 account to create a poll. Participants do not need an account.

Confidence is not the same as agreement

“I like the goal” differs from “I believe we can deliver this plan.” Someone can support the goal while seeing major delivery risks. Ask about feasibility or the conditions of a proposal.

Confidence voting fits when the group already has a shared reference point. A single confidence scale is too narrow for collecting ideas, ranking them or choosing between several alternatives.

A shared 1–5 scale

The general facil4 template runs from 1, a lack of confidence with major problems, to 5, full confidence. 2 signals serious concerns, 3 some concerns and 4 lighter reservations. The actual answer labels matter more than the numbers alone.

These levels are ordered assessments. The distance between 1 and 2 need not feel the same to a person as the distance between 4 and 5. An average is therefore a rough summary, not a precise measurement of the probability of success.

Read the distribution: two groups, the same average

Imagine four people voting 3, 3, 3 and 3. Another group votes 1, 1, 5 and 5. Both averages are 3. The first group may share unresolved questions. In the second, explore whether different information, risks or experiences explain the assessments.

Start with the distribution and missing responses. A result from only a few participants says little about the whole group. Ask for observations without labelling people by their presumed vote.

There is no universal passing threshold

Agree before voting which questions the result should trigger. An average alone should not decide whether you proceed with a plan. A single well-founded obstacle may matter even when the majority is confident.

If your organization has its own decision criteria, clarify how they apply. facil4 calculates the distribution and average but does not make an approval decision.

Move from results to action

A useful follow-up is: “What would need to change in the plan for us to feel more confident?” Record changes, owners and unresolved assumptions in your working context. Do not force people to disclose low scores.

A substantially changed proposal may benefit from a new vote. Repeating the same question without a change can let the wish for a better score displace the discussion. For the practical process, follow the step-by-step guide below.

Ready for your vote?

Open the template in the cockpit, sign in and review the question. Create and start the vote before sharing the link or QR code.

Use this template

Explore next

How to run a confidence vote

Prepare the question and scale, collect independent votes and discuss the result. A practical confidence voting process for in-person and online groups.